I use Catherine Schuyler Malcolm Cochran for Catharine Van Rensselaer Schuyler, a woman who lived from 1781 to 1857 and whose life runs like a quiet thread through the loudest years of the early American republic. She was born in Albany on 20 February 1781, the fifteenth child of Major General Philip Schuyler and Catharine Van Rensselaer. Her father wrote to George Washington on 25 February 1781 with the news. The Albany Dutch church register lists the Washingtons at the baptism on 4 March 1781, though they were absent. Washington agreed on 23 March to become a sponsor. That promise gave Catherine the later title godchild of Washington. Eight of the fifteen Schuyler children reached adulthood, and Catherine was the last of them. She held no office and published no book. Her life is a family portrait more than a public career, and I find that quiet outline compelling.
Early Life in the Schuyler Household
Philip Schuyler was born on 20 November 1733 and died on 18 November 1804. He married Catharine Van Rensselaer on 7 September 1755. The mother, also called Kitty, was born about 4 November 1734 and died on 7 March 1803. The household was large, ambitious, and closely tied to New York politics. Catherine’s siblings included Angelica Schuyler Church, Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton, Margarita “Peggy” Schuyler Van Rensselaer, John Bradstreet Schuyler, Philip Jeremiah Schuyler, Rensselaer Schuyler, and Cornelia Schuyler Morton. There were also infants who died young, including twins born in 1761 and a first John Bradstreet Schuyler who lived from 1763 to 1764.
I picture the Schuyler family tree with deep roots and broken branches. Angelica lived from 1756 to 1814 and married John Barker Church. Elizabeth lived from 1757 to 1854 and married Alexander Hamilton. Peggy lived from 1758 to 1801 and married Stephen Van Rensselaer III. John Bradstreet Schuyler, the adult brother, lived from 1765 to 1795. Philip Jeremiah lived from 1768 to 1835. Rensselaer lived from 1773 to 1847. Cornelia lived from 1776 to 1808 and married Washington Morton. Catherine was born into the next generation of that crowded house.
Marriage to Samuel Bayard Malcolm
In May 1803 Catherine married Samuel Bayard Malcolm, also written Malcom. He was a lawyer and had served as private secretary to John Adams. By January 1797 he was bound for Philadelphia to serve Adams, and on 4 March 1797 he described the inauguration and Washington’s farewell to his mother. His later years are shadowed by conflicting dates. He is sometimes given as 1776 to 1815, sometimes 1776 to 1814, and sometimes 1777 to 1817. I cannot resolve the year of his death. His final years are also tied to Stillwater.
On 15 May 1812 Samuel wrote from Utica to Thomas Jefferson asking for a federal judgeship. He said the marriage had taken him out of public life and that no Schuyler except General Hamilton had received such a place. John Adams recommended him, but no appointment came. The papers of the family also suggest a controversy over the marriage and hard feeling between the sons, though I found no clear explanation.
Catherine and Samuel had four children. Two sons reached adulthood. One Albany historian says four children, while a county history says two of the four died young. The names of the two who died young are not confirmed in the archival biographies. I leave them unnamed rather than turn uncertainty into false precision. The surviving sons were William Schuyler Malcolm and Alexander Hamilton Schuyler Malcolm.
Children and Family Ties
William Schuyler Malcolm was born at Utica on 23 February 1810 and died at Oswego on 27 February 1890. He came to Oswego in 1825 with his mother and stepfather. He went to sea at nineteen and commanded Lake Ontario vessels for twenty-three years. He was briefly a deputy United States marshal during the Patriot War of 1838 to 1839. In 1842 he married, though the wife’s name appears in conflicting forms. He was Oswego’s first alderman in 1848 and a United States assistant engineer from 1854 to 1869. On 14 April 1829 he wrote to his mother from Smyrna. That letter is a small window into a son far from home and a mother keeping the family ledger in Oswego.
Alexander Hamilton Schuyler Malcolm was born about 1815 and died on 2 December 1888. He is buried at Oswego. His name repeats his uncle Alexander Hamilton. I found no proof that the echo was deliberate, so I state the name and not the motive. An 1840 letter to him from James and William survives. Little else about him is clear.
Catherine’s family ties reached into the next generation. Alexander Hamilton Jr., son of Elizabeth and Alexander Hamilton, lived from 1786 to 1875, so Catherine was his aunt. Stephen Van Rensselaer IV, son of Peggy and Stephen Van Rensselaer III, lived from 1789 to 1868, so Catherine was his maternal aunt. The Schuyler household was a web, and Catherine sat at a quiet intersection of it.
Second Marriage to James Cochran
In 1822 Catherine married her first cousin James Cochran. He was born in Albany on 11 February 1769 and died in Oswego on 7 November 1848. His parents were Dr. John Cochran and Gertrude Schuyler, a sister of Philip Schuyler. James graduated from Columbia in 1788. He was a regent of the University of the State of New York from 1796 to 1820. As a Federalist he represented New York’s 10th district in the House from 4 March 1797 to 3 March 1799. He was a state senator from 1 July 1813 to 30 June 1817, though one account gives 1814 to 1818. In Oswego he was postmaster from 27 September 1841 to 21 July 1845 and edited the Oswego Democratic Gazette.
James first married Eleanor P. Barclay on 14 July 1798. She died young, and no child of that marriage is established. Catherine and James are said to have had one child, but the child is unnamed in the archival biographies. I treat that child as unconfirmed. The couple moved to Oswego in 1825 or 1826. Catherine filed a will at Oswego in August 1856. She died in August 1857 and was buried at Riverside Cemetery. One date given for her death is 26 August 1857; I keep the month and note the uncertainty. I found no cause of death.
The Raid Legend and Quiet Records
On 7 August 1781 raiders attacked The Pastures, the Schuyler home. Catherine was an infant in the house. A party under Captain John Walter Meyer broke in. Barry St. Leger wrote that servants fought until wounded or disarmed and that the uproar of Mrs. Schuyler and the cries of the children helped drive the attackers off. The famous story says Peggy carried Catherine upstairs while a tomahawk struck the banister. That detail appears in print in the 1830s but is missing from Schuyler’s letters and Loyalist records. I treat the raid as real and the banister story as legend. The legend is a bright coat over a thin frame.
Quieter records matter too. William’s 1829 letter from Smyrna and Samuel’s 1812 judgeship request are small human documents. They show a family managing distance, ambition, and disappointment. I found no civil death record, no confirmed Cochran child, no dollar value for the estate, no published writing by Catherine, and no identified portrait.
Timeline at a Glance
20 November 1733 | Philip Schuyler born |
about 4 November 1734 | Catharine Van Rensselaer born |
7 September 1755 | Philip and Catharine marry |
20 February 1781 | Catherine born in Albany |
4 March 1781 | Baptism; Washingtons listed but absent |
23 March 1781 | Washington accepts sponsorship |
7 August 1781 | Raid on The Pastures |
May 1803 | Catherine marries Samuel Bayard Malcolm |
23 February 1810 | William Schuyler Malcolm born at Utica |
15 May 1812 | Samuel asks Jefferson for a judgeship |
about 1815 | Alexander Hamilton Malcolm born |
1822 | Catherine marries James Cochran |
1825 or 1826 | Move to Oswego |
August 1856 | Catherine files her will at Oswego |
August 1857 | Catherine dies and is buried at Riverside Cemetery |
FAQ
Who was Catherine Schuyler Malcolm Cochran?
She was Catharine Van Rensselaer Schuyler, born in Albany on 20 February 1781 and dead in August 1857. She was the youngest child of Philip Schuyler and Catharine Van Rensselaer. She married Samuel Bayard Malcolm in May 1803 and James Cochran in 1822. She was a sister to Angelica, Elizabeth, Peggy, John Bradstreet, Philip Jeremiah, Rensselaer, and Cornelia. She was an aunt to Alexander Hamilton Jr. and Stephen Van Rensselaer IV.
How was she connected to George Washington?
Her father wrote Washington on 25 February 1781 and asked him and Martha Washington to be sponsors. The baptism on 4 March 1781 listed them, but they were absent. Washington agreed on 23 March 1781 to become a sponsor. That sponsorship, not adoption, is the basis for calling Catherine a godchild of Washington.
Did Peggy Schuyler really carry her from the raid?
The raid on The Pastures on 7 August 1781 is real. Catherine was an infant in the house. The story that Peggy carried her upstairs while a tomahawk struck the banister is a later legend. The tomahawk detail appears in print in the 1830s and is missing from Schuyler’s letters and Loyalist records. I keep the documented infant and the dramatic legend separate.
How many children did Catherine have?
She had four children with Samuel Bayard Malcolm. Two sons reached adulthood. William Schuyler Malcolm lived from 1810 to 1890, and Alexander Hamilton Schuyler Malcolm lived from about 1815 to 1888. Two other children died young, but their names are not confirmed in the archival biographies. Catherine and James Cochran are said to have had one child, but that child is unnamed and unconfirmed.
Who was James Cochran?
James Cochran was Catherine’s first cousin and second husband. He was born in Albany on 11 February 1769 and died in Oswego on 7 November 1848. He graduated from Columbia in 1788, served in the House from 1797 to 1799, was a state senator from 1813 to 1817, and was Oswego postmaster from 1841 to 1845. He married Catherine in 1822.
Why is her name spelled several ways?
The family name appears as Schuyler, and her first name appears as Catharine and Catherine. Her first husband’s surname appears as Malcolm and Malcom. I use Catherine Schuyler Malcolm Cochran for clarity, but the variants are part of the record and part of the difficulty of tracing her.
What remains unresolved about her life?
Her exact death date is uncertain beyond August 1857. No cause of death was found. The year of Samuel’s death is unresolved, with 1814, 1815, and 1817 all appearing. The names of the two Malcolm children who died young are unconfirmed. The Cochran child is unnamed. The dollar value of her estate and any portrait of her were not found.